Homemade S’mores Ice Cream


Yesterday I shared a fun recipe for S’mores ice cream over on the sweet Eighteen25 blog. I am absolutely in love with this simple, no-machine-required homemade ice cream recipe. All you need are two ingredients for your ice cream base, then whatever flavors and toppings you can dream up! So fun and easy, and perfect for these hot summer months.


Scoop s’mores ice cream between two graham crackers for S’mores Ice Cream Bars. Delish!

Here’s the link to my S’mores Ice Cream post over on Eighteen25.

And here’s the link to my original, no-machine-required homemade ice cream recipe, with lots of ideas for fun flavor combinations. There are tons more ideas from you guys in the comments, I love reading what ya’ll come up with! I have tried way too many of them.

Have a great weekend!

You May Also Like:

45 Responses
  1. Jeanelle

    I made this last night and I can’t believe how yummy it tasted even before it went in the freezer. I made a few other varieties earlier this month and am still amazed at how easy it is to make ice cream without a machine. Thanks so much for sharing these recipes!

  2. theurbanbaker

    S’mores are already a fav in our house, add “ice cream” at the end of it and I think the whole neighborhood will be showing up at my door step! Yum!

  3. Jennifer

    Thanks Amanda! I made the S’mores one last night and it is UNBELIEVABLE! My hubby had it for breakfast this morning!! This afternoon I am going to try the Nutella and also the Cookies and Cream. I am new to your blog and I am loving it!

  4. Jen @ My Kitchen Addiction

    Yum! This ice cream looks great… And, I just love the photo of the ice cream sandwiched in the graham crackers.

  5. Christie

    I attempted to make the nutella / pb chips no churn ice cream and it didn’t freeze up very well – it was a like pudding. What did I do wrong? I used a hand mixer instead of the stand mixer – would that make a difference? I’m positive it’s user error.

    1. Christie

      Never mind.. it just needed a couple more hours of freezer time. It turned out great. We’ll definitely be making more!

  6. Jeniffer

    Hey Amanda :)
    I just found your blog the other day, and I love it! But I have a question, do you think I’ll be able to whisk the cream like that or can i only be that way with a machine? Thank you :)

    1. Amanda

      You probably could, but your arm would get very, very tired!! :) I would do it with an electric mixer, either a stand mixer or a hand-held mixer is fine :)

  7. Jenni Roseland

    made this last night with my kids, ate it this morning for breakfast (bad, i know), but they couldn’t wait! it tasted as good as it looks! my son is especially thankful!

  8. Brooke @ Food Woolf

    This looks incredibly dangerous. I’m afraid to even attempt making this, for fear I’ll never eat anything else, ever again. :)

  9. ambar

    I made a cupcake version of this yesterday and my hubby is nuts about it, I just added 3/4 of a bottle of the smucker’s magic shell cupcake flavor, and added some nonperils as well. absolutely amazing

  10. victoria

    hi amanda :)

    i have been trying to email you but apparantely i am struggeling with my new computer, and i could find your email adress anywhere so i am just going to leave you my email in a comment instead!

    i love your fonts! i have them installed on my old computer :) my problem is, i bought a new computer today and i can not figure out how to install them again!! i have windows 7, so neither the windows xp directions or windows vista directions are working for me :( please help me.. i cant live without your amazing fonts!! hehe

    if you could maybe just email me back [so that i know you saw this:] i would appreciate it so so much!!

    thank you :) !!


  11. Kiran @

    Yay! Finally, a no fuss ice cream recipe. Can’t blame the girl for not owning an ice cream machine ;) This looks divine in so many levels!

  12. Amanda

    I made it the other night with strawberries, banana, and white chocolate. It was amazing! The condensed milk did something magical to the banana and white chocolate combination… I was going to blog it but then I ate it all! ;)

  13. sue beaty

    im gonna eat all this good good food. my sig. other will love me, then im gonna have to join weight watchers, then go back again. its a vicious cycle:)

  14. Jessie

    Sounds Delish!!! Can’t wait to try this one…
    I’ve already made ice-cream with your recipe a few times (: thx!!!
    The flavors I’ve made are… Black Cherry w/ nuts and chocolate and the other was Coconut w/ white chocolate. Came out sooo good!

  15. Ann

    Wow! We just finished our first round of homemade ice cream from the other post (which was phenomenal). S’mores ice cream? Unimaginable! :)

  16. Kathleen

    I, honestly love everything you post on this blog. Smore ice cream?! I only wish I had a scoop in front of me RIGHT now!

  17. Mel Tardy

    I have seen your other ice cream recipes and they all are right up my alley. I do have a question tho, I recently recieved the ice cream attachment for my kitchenaid and love using it. With this recipe, even though I don’t need to use the churner, would it affect it poorly if I did?

  18. Brooke

    That is such a cute idea!! At first I thought it was just going to be s’mores flavored ice cream…but putting a twist on an ice cream sandwich/s’more sounds sooo delicious.

  19. Erin @ Brownie Bites

    Oh my goodness those sandwiches are so cute.. s’mores ice cream sounds HEAVENLY! I don’t have the patience for an ice cream maker so I’m all about simple no-fuss ice cream recipes. Thanks for sharing!

  20. Diane

    Looks absolutely delicious…I can’t wait to try this! Have you been doing any scrapbooking lately?? I love looking at your pages!!!

  21. Southern Gal

    Amanda, you’re killing me over here! I’m trying to run and cut back the calories, but the ice cream, oh this ice cream, is killing me! I tried Nutella with Heath bars over the 4th. I left that evil concoction at my parents’ house so I wouldn’t eat any more than a serving. Now s’mores…

    Send help.

  22. Angie @ Bigbearswife

    Smores are like a must have for the summer! Ice cream as well, so this = perfect! plus I love the bowl!

  23. Sandy

    This recipe looks delicious, and easy. Any summertime pics available of Howie and Miley? Their pictures make my day. I need a Howie and Miley fix………….

    1. Denise

      Isn’t it funny how those little dogs can make your day?! I love when they are boating! Navigating! :) Woof!

  24. The Mrs @ Success Along the Weigh

    Well I make my smores with nutella (cinnamon graham crackers, nutella and marshmallow fluff if no campire is roaring) so I know nutella will make its way in that bad boy! :-)

  25. Averie @ Love Veggies and Yoga

    Smores ice cream? Looks and sounds PERFECT!

    Have a wonderful weekend and please eat lots of smores ice cream over the weekend :)

Do you have a question or comment?

Meet Kevin & Amanda

Kevin and Amanda

We love to travel and to eat! Here we share our favorite quick and easy recipes, plus travel tips and guides for our favorite places around the world. If you have any questions about what camera I use or how I edit my photos, check out my photography tutorials.


Subscribe via Email: