I have a husband who is obsessed with all things Banana, Peanut Butter, and Chocolate. And banana pudding is his absolute favorite! I was never really a banana pudding person before, but his obsession with banana, peanut butter, and chocolate is so strong it has actually started to grow on me a bit! :) So I am always looking for ways to incorporate his favorite flavor trifecta in treats for him. :) I think ice cream is his second favorite dessert of all time, so this easy, no machine required Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls was perfect!
If you’ve never made this easy, two-ingredient ice cream, you must absolutely put it on your must-make list before summer ends! :) Here’s how I jazzed it up with banana, peanut butter, and chocolate.
Heavy cream and sweetened condensed milk are the two main players in this recipe, then you can add whatever flavors and toppings you want to create your perfect ice cream. I added bananas, banana pudding, peanut butter, hot fudge, and mini Nilla wafers to make Banana Pudding Ice Cream.
Just start with sweetened condensed milk, and add it to a large bowl, big enough for all your toppings! :)
Add some banana cream jello… Thanks to my lovely assistant and hand model hubby here! He was really excited about this ice cream. :)
Whisk the instant pudding into the sweetened condensed milk until dissolved. I thought I could do this with a spatula. Hahahaha. Um, no. You might even want to use a KitchenAid or mixer here! I made Kevin take over. :)
Next add in some sliced bananas, for texture. Everything’s totally optional here. You can add whatever you want! :)
Some crushed mini Nilla wafers. So addicted to these darn cookies!
Now with a mixer, whip your very cold heavy cream until it looks like whipped cream. Then fold it into the sweetened condensed milk mixture.
Now before all this started, I placed a bowl with 1/2 cup peanut butter in the freezer to harden. Kevin specified that he wanted this ice cream to just have swirls of peanut butter, not be completely peanut butter flavored. ;)
So just pinch off teaspoon-size dollops of peanut butter and fold them into the ice cream for perfect peanut butter swirls. Next do the same with the room temperature hot fudge topping for dreamy fudge swirls.
That is IT you guys!! Pour it all into a two-quart container and freeze overnight.
Can I tell you how hard it is to wait for this?! Go ahead and sneak a bite now though. Quality control and all.
And when it comes out, you have an ultra creamy, ultra dreamy ice cream that’s 100% custom made and perfect for your palate!
Now to the fun part! Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings would like to offer one Kevin & Amanda reader everything needed to prepare for an ice cream party, including two of the latest Smucker’s Toppings varieties! Taste-test these new products with family and friends during a summer celebration – whether it’s a backyard barbecue, birthday party or just an everyday moment.
Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings Party Kit: ($150 value)
- Smucker’s Spoonable Blueberry Topping and Smucker’s Hot Caramel Microwavable Topping
- Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk — three varieties
- $75 Walmart gift card — for heavy cream and toppings!
- Smucker’s Bowls & Scoop — they change colors when you put ice cream in them!! So fun!
- Portable iPod speakers
- Exclusive Recipes
How to Enter
To be entered to win the Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings Party Kit, all you have to do is leave a comment on this post. What is your perfect flavor combo?? :)
Contest ends Wednesday, August 8 at 8 am CST. One entry per person, please. Winner must have a US mailing address. Winner will be chosen at random and notified by email. Giveaway graciously provided by Smuckers.
If you’re on Facebook, come check us out here! :)
Time’s Up!
The winner of the Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings Party Kit is:
#484 Delaine Brown: Caramel, pecans and chocolate are my favorites! I think I was a snickers or turtle in my past life! This recipe is definately a keeper too though!
Congrats Delaine! I’ve sent you an email! :)
Good luck!!! :)
Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls
1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk
1 pkg (3.4 oz) banana cream Jell-o instant pudding
1 banana, sliced
1/2 cup mini Nilla wafers, broken in half
2 cups (1 pint) heavy cream
1/2 cup peanut butter
1/2 cup hot fudge ice cream topping
1. Measure the peanut butter into a bowl, and place in the freezer for about 30 minutes to firm up. Meanwhile, whisk Jell-o into sweetened condensed milk. Stir in sliced banana and Nilla wafers.
2. Using an electric mixer (with a whisk attachment, if you have one), beat heavy cream until it resembles whipped cream. Fold the whipped cream into the sweetened condensed milk mixture. Retrieve peanut butter from the freezer and pinch off teaspoon-sized dollops and drop into the ice cream. Next squeeze teaspoon-sized dollops of room temperature hot fudge topping into the ice cream. Gently fold it all together.
3. Store in a two-quart container and freeze overnight. Serve the next day with topped with whipped cream, heated hot fudge topping, and extra crushed Nilla wafers! Enjoy!!
)
Make for: Dessert, Giveaway
Tags: Ice Cream, Perfect for Parties
Follow Amanda on 
689 Comments
Yummmmmy! I’m thinking a combo of caramel and Heath Bar sounds delish!
Hot fudge and Pretzel
so hard to decide! probably toasted coconut and pralines since my husband doesn’t like either!
Peanut butter and chocolate…..yum!
I love peanut butter and chocolate, but my husband and I discovered the combo of marshmallow and caramel in a concrete from Culvers!
I am a huge peanut butter fan and my husband is a banana pudding lover…his mom always makes it for him the from scratch custard kind…can’t wait to try this ice cream!
I loooooove mint chocolate chip.
I think I’m in love! All of my favorite flavors together in ice cream form? I don’t think I will be able to share once I get it made!
My favorite combo is strawberry and cheesecake. I might try making this ice cream using the cheesecake instant pudding and some yummy fresh strawberries!
Thank you!
Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge and Caramel, add bananas and it just gets even better. Can’t wait to try this.
This sounds delicious! I think I’ll be making it for my hubby too! My favorite combo is chocolate raspberry.
I love mint chocolate chip as well as peanut butter and chocolate
Peanut Butter and chocolate of course!
This looks good..will have to try! Something with raspberry and chocolate would be my choice.
Vanilla ice cream with brownies and raspberries
I love chocolate chip cookie dough!
Yum! And anything with chocolate, marshmallows and pecans!
Favorite combo is (and always will be!) cookie dough (:
My favorite combo would have to be chocolate and peanut butter!!! Mmmm
Caramel ice cream, chocolate chunks and caramel swirled in!
I can’t think of anything that beats chocolate and peanut butter! Cookie dough is awesome, too.
peanut butter and animal cookies are my new favorite froyo mix ins!
That combination sounds so good. I’ll have to try
I love cookie dough with cake batter but also love adding butterfinger candy bar to ice cream…yum!
Anything with crunchy toffee and/or fudge!
My husband and I love Chocolate ,Banana, Graham Crackers, and Cream Cheese, with a little Coconut. Yummy!
My perfect flavor combo is chocolate and peanut butter. Or chocolate and raspberry. Or chocolate and …well, you get the idea. ;) I’m all about the chocolate.
Chocolate and peanut butter!!
Vanilla Bean ice cream with Hot Caramel Sauce and pecans! Oh yum!
Yummy…. would love to win this!!!
My fave is without a doubt is chocolate chip. Nothing fancy, but, oh so good!!!
I love mocha flavored ice cream with mini chocolate chips!!
I like strawberries, marshmellow creme, and cream cheese together. Sounds like a strawberry cheese-quake ice cream to me. lol. I hope I win this prize because I am an ice cream lover. Thanks for the chance to win, Becky
This looks amazing!!! So nice and easy. With the items that you already have in the pantry. Can’t wait to try this. Thanks:)
This is a hard one to answer but my newest favorite flavor is Green Tea. I say Green Tea with pistachios and mild chocolate swirls :)
This recipe looks awesome! My favorite flavor combo is chocolate and strawberry..Yum, Yum!
I love pistachio with coconut and almonds
Chocolate and PB!!
My husband and I are like your husband! We love peanut butter but prefer it to have strips of thick peanut butter or bites. When you posted that last ice cream recipe, I actually made a chocolate/peanut butter swirl by taking peanut butter and freezing it in strips on wax paper and then pushing it into the ice cream just before I put it in the freezer to freeze. It was incredible.
I love vanilla, carmel, and graham crackers with chopped peanuts!
mmmm my fave is dark chocolate and walnuts. yum
This may seem childish, but I love peanut butter and marshmallow fluff! SO good.
mmmm.. chocolate & banana.. awesome thanks!!
Yummy summer treat! I could go for this it – it is so hot right now!
Banana Ice Cream is amazing….and I love it with chocolate and peanut butter, just like your husband. Can’t wait to make this!
I always go for the chocolate & peanut butter combo… Thanks for this wonderful recipe, Amanda!
I love, love, love buttered pecan!
I’m pretty old school and would have to say vanilla with hot fudge is my favorite! :)
I would add caramel and chopped pecans!
My fave would have to mint chocolate chip…or fudge brownie with chocolate drizzled over vanilla icecream:)
OMG – I have tried your ice cream recipe many times but couldn’t figure out how to do banana. May fave flavor. Thank You thank you thank you thank you. I am going to the store today to get the stuff. I made white chocolate ice cream, crushed frozen raspberries and smuckers hot fudge and layered it. Yum yum.
I love dark chocolate and coffee flavors together!
perfect flavor combo – raspberry and chocolate. no brainer :)
Brownies and vanilla ice cream! Love your banana pudding ice cream!!
Mmmm, my fave is cake batter and fresh berries with some whipped cream! YUM! Thanks for the chance to win!
Cookies & cream
Anything with caramel and a touch of salt!!
Oooh…I have never heard of “no machine” ice cream and I will definitely try it! I like so many kinds of ice creams…the more oooey gooey-ness, the better! I hope win! :-) Thanks for the recipe!
Peanut Butter Cups and Chocolate!!! Oh baby! :)
salty caramel and peanut butter!
Lately, chocolate and Biscoff! This ice cream would be awesome with Biscoff in it. Can’t wait to try it.
My fave ice cream is Blue Moon…so maybe a blue moon marshmallow ripple would be divine!
Yum! I love chocolate and peanut butter. The perfect combo!
The banana pudding flavor seems like it would be pretty tasty to me.
I’d have to go with gooey brownie chunks & chocolate chips!!! :)
Peanut Butter and Banana for sure : )
Vanilla Ice Cream with Peanut Butter, Chocolate, Caramel and Banana!!!! YUM!
Ice cream that tastes like a Milky Way.
Love marshmallow and chocolate
Salt + Chocolate is the best combo ever!
Love your ice cream creations! I’m not a huge chocolate fan, so the sweet and tangy combination of raspberries and lemons are keeping my taste buds satisfied :)
Caramel and pecans….trying your recipe today! My mom would love he banana version.
I would say a banana split mix would be great!
Caramel and toffee!
Sweet cream and Heath bars!!
I love chocolate with almonds and dark cherries! :)
Pistachio, lemon cookie, and pineapple!
That looks delicious!!! Anything with chocolate and pb… and oh I love rocky road… Yummy!!!
Oh my this looks soooo good. Yumm, & Gonna have to give this a try soon!
My perfect flavor combo is probably peanut butter and chocolate, but give me anything sweet and I’m good to go – no need to discriminate! :)
I love anything with fudge and peanut butter cups.
I’m with your husband Kevin there is nothing better than Banana Pudding and I’m with you Amanda, I am addicted to Nilla Wafers no matter what size and just so I have enough of them when I get around to making a Banana Pudding I buy two boxes at a time! I am going to make this ice cream today!!!!!!! Oh how it made my mouth water just reading about it! Thank you for sharing.
I love anything with chocolate and peanut butter!
Caramel, pecans and chocolate are my favorites! I think I was a snickers or turtle in my past life! This recipe is definately a keeper too though!
That looks fabulous! I love peanut butter and banana. Chocolate and peanut butter is my favorite combination.
Your recipe sounds so yummy! I have got to make it! I also would love hazelnut/chocolate spread mixed into vanilla with hot fudge sauce on top.
Pretzel, chocolate & oeanut butter with malted ice cream…yummy!
Chocolate and cherries… But its ice cream so Anything works…RIGHT!
Wow! There’s so many!! :/
I’d have to say my favorite at the moment is apples/peanut butter.
I love chocolate chip mint!
That looks so yummy on such a hot day like today!!!!
My husband will love this!! He, like Kevin, loves chocolate, banana, and peanut butter!
i looove caramel, vanilla, and dark chocolate!
Anything that goes w/ peanut butter & chocolate!
Oh…my…YUM! I would pick NUTELLA! Anything with nutella! Thanks for the chance ti win!
I love cheesecake flavored ice cream but I have a case of peaches where some of them will be turned into ice cream! ;)
Hot Fudge and Caramel!
Chocolate and Strawberry!
Chocolate and peanut butter are awesome!
Chocolate and peanut butter…hold the banana. ;)
I love chocolate ice cream with cookie dough!