Menu

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls

•August 6, 2012
Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

This delicious Banana Pudding Ice Cream recipe is made with fudgy chocolate peanut butter swirls. It’s the perfect sweet and refreshing summer dessert!Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls

I have a husband who is obsessed with all things Banana, Peanut Butter, and Chocolate. I am always looking for ways to incorporate his favorite flavor trifecta in treats for him. Ice cream is one of his favorite desserts of all time, so this easy, no machine required Banana Pudding Homemade Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls was perfect!

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

If you’ve never made this easy, two-ingredient ice cream, you must absolutely put it on your must-make list before summer ends! :) Here’s how I jazzed it up with banana, peanut butter, and chocolate.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Heavy cream and sweetened condensed milk are the two main players in this recipe, then you can add whatever flavors and toppings you want to create your perfect ice cream. I added bananas, banana pudding, peanut butter, hot fudge, and mini Nilla wafers to make Banana Pudding Ice Cream.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Banana Pudding Ice Cream Recipe

Just start with sweetened condensed milk, and add it to a large bowl, big enough for all your toppings! :)

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Add some banana cream jello… Thanks to my lovely assistant and hand model hubby here! He was really excited about this homemade ice cream. :)

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Whisk the instant pudding into the sweetened condensed milk until dissolved. I thought I could do this with a spatula. Hahahaha. Um, no. You might even want to use a KitchenAid or mixer here! I made Kevin take over. :)

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Next add in some sliced bananas, for texture. Everything’s totally optional here. You can add whatever you want! :)

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Some crushed mini Nilla wafers. So addicted to these darn cookies!

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Now with a mixer, whip your very cold heavy cream until it looks like whipped cream. Then fold it into the sweetened condensed milk mixture.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Now before all this started, I placed a bowl with 1/2 cup peanut butter in the freezer to harden. Kevin specified that he wanted this ice cream to just have swirls of peanut butter, not be completely peanut butter flavored. ;)

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

So just pinch off teaspoon-size dollops of peanut butter and fold them into the ice cream for perfect peanut butter swirls. Next do the same with the room temperature hot fudge topping for dreamy fudge swirls.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

That is IT you guys!! Pour it all into a two-quart container and freeze overnight.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Can I tell you how hard it is to wait for this?! Go ahead and sneak a bite now though. Quality control and all.

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

And when it comes out, you have an ultra creamy, ultra dreamy ice cream that’s 100% custom made and perfect for your palate!

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Swirls

Now to the fun part! Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings would like to offer one Kevin & Amanda reader everything needed to prepare for an ice cream party, including two of the latest Smucker’s Toppings varieties! Taste-test these new products with family and friends during a summer celebration – whether it’s a backyard barbecue, birthday party or just an everyday moment.

Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings Party Kit: ($150 value)

  • Smucker’s Spoonable Blueberry Topping and Smucker’s Hot Caramel Microwavable Topping
  • Eagle Brand Sweetened Condensed Milk — three varieties
  • $75 Walmart gift card — for heavy cream and toppings!
  • Smucker’s Bowls & Scoop — they change colors when you put ice cream in them!! So fun!
  • Portable iPod speakers
  • Exclusive Recipes

How to Enter

To be entered to win the Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings Party Kit, all you have to do is leave a comment on this post. What is your perfect flavor combo?? :)

Contest ends Wednesday, August 8 at 8 am CST. One entry per person, please. Winner must have a US mailing address. Winner will be chosen at random and notified by email. Giveaway graciously provided by Smuckers.

If you’re on Facebook, come check us out here! :)

Time’s Up!

The winner of the Smucker’s Ice Cream Toppings Party Kit is:

#484 Delaine Brown: Caramel, pecans and chocolate are my favorites! I think I was a snickers or turtle in my past life! This recipe is definately a keeper too though!

Congrats Delaine! I’ve sent you an email! :)

Good luck!!! :)

Print
Image of Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls

Banana Pudding Ice Cream with Fudge Swirls

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star No reviews
  • Prep Time: 45 minutes
  • Total Time: 45 minutes
  • Yield: About 12 servings 1x
  • Category: Dessert
  • Method: No Bake
  • Cuisine: American
Print

Description

This delicious Banana Pudding Ice Cream recipe is made with fudgy chocolate peanut butter swirls. It’s the perfect sweet and refreshing summer dessert!

Scale

Ingredients

  • 1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk
  • 1 pkg (3.4 oz) banana cream Jell-o instant pudding
  • 1 banana, sliced
  • 1/2 cup mini Nilla wafers, broken in half
  • 2 cups (1 pint) heavy cream
  • 1/2 cup peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup hot fudge ice cream topping

Instructions

  1. Measure the peanut butter into a bowl, and place in the freezer for about 30 minutes to firm up. Meanwhile, whisk Jell-o into sweetened condensed milk. Stir in sliced banana and Nilla wafers.
  2. Using an electric mixer (with a whisk attachment, if you have one), beat heavy cream until it resembles whipped cream. Fold the whipped cream into the sweetened condensed milk mixture. Retrieve peanut butter from the freezer and pinch off teaspoon-sized dollops and drop into the ice cream. Next squeeze teaspoon-sized dollops of room temperature hot fudge topping into the ice cream. Gently fold it all together.
  3. Store in a two-quart container and freeze overnight. Serve the next day with topped with whipped cream, heated hot fudge topping, and extra crushed Nilla wafers! Enjoy!!

You May Also Like:

Previous PostNext Post
697 Responses
  6. marisa
    Reply

    I made this today (minus the peanut butter) and I’m anxiously waiting for tomorrow morning so I can finally try it! It’ll be my breakfast!

  13. Veronica M.
    Reply

    Can’t wait to try this. Yum! I think this would be good with Biscoff spread instead of peanut butter. Love the tip of freezing the peanut butter and hot fudge before hand so it would swirl into ice cream.

  21. Mara @ Super Savings
    Reply

    Ooh, just one flavor is tough! Usually something along the lines of Oreo/Butterfinger/Reese’s/Fudge…… =) This banana/PB/fudge combo looks amazing though! Definitely “pinned” and will try!

    ~ Mara

  30. Amrita
    Reply

    I share your husband’s obsession of banana, peanut butter and chocolate!

    Has he tried the Ben and Jerry’s Greek Frozen Yogurt yet?? There is a peanut butter banana flavor!

    Thanks for the giveaway!

  43. Susie Swedowski
    Reply

    Looks delish! Definitely going to try this, but will drop the chocolate and add caramel. Thanks for the great recipe!

  47. Heather
    Reply

    omg…so doing this! my hubby LOVES banana pudding and I LOVE pb. Match made in heaven. My fave flavor combo is PB/banana too!

  52. Dianne
    Reply

    This looks so easy and yummy! Thanks for sharing the love!!
    Best flavor combos include (but not limited to…)roasted, salty nuts and chocolate!

  56. Marie
    Reply

    Oh, my goodness…I just showed this to The Husband and he *insisted* that I make it tonight. I love anything with chocolate and peanut butter, and my husband loves old fashioned banana pudding. So, win-win!

  57. Rosalie
    Reply

    My favorite is chocolate with caramel and peanut butter swirl and crushed up sugar cone pieces!! hungry just thinking about it!!

  59. aydee ybarra
    Reply

    this with banana and peanut butter sounds  delicious, but my favorite combination is Hazelnut Mocha Fudge Swirl

  66. Amanda S
    Reply

    Yummm, I’m totally going to make some this weekend! Hmm to many yummy choices right now Vanilla, Bourbon, and Peaches sound yummy Or Vanilla, Caramel and Blueberry!

  68. Amy
    Reply

    I’m going to recreate the “Monkey Business” ice cream Publix had last year (but doesn’t have this year). Banana ice cream with fudge swirls and chocolate covered peanuts. Yum!

  73. shawn
    Reply

    my standard favorite was anything with chocolate or oreos but then my husband introduced me to dark chocolate and bing cherries. wow. thanks for the recipe, now i can make any flavor without needing an ice cream maker.

  74. Melissa Edwards
    Reply

    I like tropical blends of ice cream. Pineapple with nuts, coconut, bananas and some hot fudge swirled in. Yummmmm!

  78. Tonya D
    Reply

    My favorite flavor would have brownie bits and hot fudge and caramel in a butter pecan ice cream. Mmmm

    Thanks for the many great recipes!

  89. Regina
    Reply

    Who knew making ice cream was so easy…i wonder if you could do the same with chocolate pudding? Might have to give that a try – chocolate peanut butter ice cream!

  99. Cynde
    Reply

    I love Peanut butter Ice Cream with choclate swirls and peanut butter cups. Yum! My favorite. Thanks for the chance at the drawing for all the goodies. It has all my favorites thrown in there, well the tastes will all be in there anyway!

  104. Taylor
    Reply

    That looks amazing. My hubby is also obsessed with peanut butter and banana, so I’ll have to try this for him!

    My perfect flavor would have to be chocolate hazelnut. I’m nothing if not a chocoholic, and adding the hazelnut flavor gives everything an extra kick that just can’t be beat!

  111. Erin @ The Spiffy Cookie
    Reply

    My perfect flavor combo is peanut butter and chocolate. I cannot get enough of it! Although most recently I’ve come to enjoy mixing funfetti cake batter and peanut butter.

  115. amanda kay tea
    Reply

    My fave flavor combos are chocolate, peanut butter & vanilla …mmmm mmm. i am making that ice cream dessert this weekend for sure!!!

  126. Becky Johnson
    Reply

    We make your no machine ice cream all the time. I loooove oreos, chocolate syrup (to make it choc ice cream), and some hard shell to make fudge swirl. But recently we tried some without the sweetened condensed milk and subbed honey instead for a more natural sweetener – soooo good.

  133. Jo Anna Grimsley
    Reply

    What a terrific giveaway; thanks for the opportunity to win. I’m with your hubby–you can’t beat pb and chocolate; will have to try the banana too!

  134. Penny
    Reply

    This sounds so yummy! My favorite is Vanilla ice cream, caramel and pralines. Although After I try this recipe It may be Bananna Pudding LOL!

  138. Wendi Hamel
    Reply

    I can’t wait to try your flavor combo…one of my favorite ice cream combo is cake batter and choc. frosting OMG!!!! Great giveaway, thanks!!!!

  146. Betsy Pratt
    Reply

    Hi Amanda,
    I had no idea that you could make ice cream without a machine! That is such DANGEROUS information! ;) My fave dessert flavors are salted caramel and peanut butter. I just adore peanut butter anything. Keep these great recipes coming. You always have the best ones, including those cupcakes with the frozen brownie batter in the middle.
    Betsy in the overcast Seattle suburbs

  152. Hazydaisy
    Reply

    Today is the first time I view this site, and I am already starving after so many mouth-watering recipes… can’t wait to try them! I think my husband-to-be will be a more than willing guinea pig ;) Ice cream happens to be his favorite dessert, so I will definitely be trying this!
    As for my favorite flavor combination, it’s hard to imagine something better than the combination you already have. Delish!

  153. Annette W.
    Reply

    This flavor blows my mind. I am a banana and peanut butter lover too! Banana and anything rocks my world. One of my favorite combos for ice cream is banana and Oreo’s. Another favorite is Lemon and cherries or strawberries with white chocolate or cheesecake chunks.

  154. Diane
    Reply

    I love Vanilla Ice cream with hot fudge and a warm peanut butter and caramel drizzle and whipped topping and I love it when it’s just about to melt:)
    Amazing!
    Fun give-away!

  155. crystal maruszak
    Reply

    My goodness this sounds AMAZING as is! I would give it whirl as you have it, or maybe try one of my fave puddings, pistachio, with waffle cone bits and salted pistachios!

  156. Susan Kay
    Reply

    Have made this recipe over and over again – just can’t get enough of it at our house. Thanks for sharing it. Our favorite is chocolate and peanut butter. We’ll have to add cookies, pudding, and bananas next time.

  159. Emily W
    Reply

    Although I can’t stand peanut butter, this looks delicious! Maybe add some chocolate swirl?
    My favorite flavor combo is probably strawberry and chocolate. Mmm… now I want dessert!

  162. Jeannette
    Reply

    my perfect flavor combo is raspberries and lemon!! they are both such bright flavors that they play off each other really well!! and when i’m feeling not so healthy ;P i love the caramel/chocolate combo!!

  173. terry tougas
    Reply

    This sounds absolutely yummy! I am definitely going to try~ love banana pudding and nilla wafers. Peanut butter and chocolate and maybe some heath bar tossed in!

  175. Denise G
    Reply

    I like regular old vanilla, but with lots of “stuff” in it :) Big Oreo chunks and anything cake-batter/sprinkle-related are my fav! And marshmallows– the little crunchy ones like in cereal.

  178. Denise Kasbohm
    Reply

    My favorite combo would be Peanut Butter and Chocolate…..But I am thinking this Peanut Butter and Banana might win!! :o)

  181. Deea @ Sprinkle Some Sunshine
    Reply

    I just had it this morning & it’s my new favorite! Coconut almond with chocolate swirls…mmmmm!

  183. Ms Langley
    Reply

    Everything about this recipe screams eat me NOW! My husband loooves bananas pudding so I can’t wait to make it for him….the best part is the peanutbutter hands down :-)

  186. Janelle
    Reply

    Yum! I am going to try to make Mango Cheesecake Swirl Ice Cream with some fresh mango and some leftover cheesecake from The Cheesecake Factory. (When I win the Smucker’s contest, of course!) :)

  189. M.C. Phillips
    Reply

    I love pretzels with chocolate and peanut butter. We did that a few years ago and I had forgotten about it! Yum!

  193. Audry Barrie
    Reply

    I love peanut butter ice cream with chocolate covered peanutes chocolate and caramel swirels all in a chocolate dipped waffle cone….my idea of heaved but your banana pudding with peanut butter and chocolate sounds like secod to that.

  200. JennAtFFP
    Reply

    I love cheesecake flavored ice cream but I have a case of peaches where some of them will be turned into ice cream! ;)

  210. JulieBee
    Reply

    Your recipe sounds so yummy! I have got to make it! I also would love hazelnut/chocolate spread mixed into vanilla with hot fudge sauce on top.

  212. Delaine Brown
    Reply

    Caramel, pecans and chocolate are my favorites! I think I was a snickers or turtle in my past life! This recipe is definately a keeper too though!

  214. Ashley
    Reply

    I’m with your husband Kevin there is nothing better than Banana Pudding and I’m with you Amanda, I am addicted to Nilla Wafers no matter what size and just so I have enough of them when I get around to making a Banana Pudding I buy two boxes at a time! I am going to make this ice cream today!!!!!!! Oh how it made my mouth water just reading about it! Thank you for sharing.

  216. Olivia Williams
    Reply

    My perfect flavor combo is probably peanut butter and chocolate, but give me anything sweet and I’m good to go – no need to discriminate! :)

  225. Alyssa M
    Reply

    Love your ice cream creations! I’m not a huge chocolate fan, so the sweet and tangy combination of raspberries and lemons are keeping my taste buds satisfied :)

  235. April was in CT now CA
    Reply

    Lately, chocolate and Biscoff! This ice cream would be awesome with Biscoff in it. Can’t wait to try it.

  238. Colleen
    Reply

    Oooh…I have never heard of “no machine” ice cream and I will definitely try it! I like so many kinds of ice creams…the more oooey gooey-ness, the better! I hope win! :-) Thanks for the recipe!

  245. Jan
    Reply

    OMG – I have tried your ice cream recipe many times but couldn’t figure out how to do banana. May fave flavor. Thank You thank you thank you thank you. I am going to the store today to get the stuff. I made white chocolate ice cream, crushed frozen raspberries and smuckers hot fudge and layered it. Yum yum.

  251. Amy Doninger
    Reply

    Banana Ice Cream is amazing….and I love it with chocolate and peanut butter, just like your husband. Can’t wait to make this!

  257. Brandy
    Reply

    My husband and I are like your husband! We love peanut butter but prefer it to have strips of thick peanut butter or bites. When you posted that last ice cream recipe, I actually made a chocolate/peanut butter swirl by taking peanut butter and freezing it in strips on wax paper and then pushing it into the ice cream just before I put it in the freezer to freeze. It was incredible.

  261. Mia Ferreira
    Reply

    This is a hard one to answer but my newest favorite flavor is Green Tea. I say Green Tea with pistachios and mild chocolate swirls :)

  262. wendy
    Reply

    This looks amazing!!! So nice and easy. With the items that you already have in the pantry. Can’t wait to try this. Thanks:)

  263. Becky
    Reply

    I like strawberries, marshmellow creme, and cream cheese together. Sounds like a strawberry cheese-quake ice cream to me. lol. I hope I win this prize because I am an ice cream lover. Thanks for the chance to win, Becky

  269. Candy M.
    Reply

    My perfect flavor combo is chocolate and peanut butter. Or chocolate and raspberry. Or chocolate and …well, you get the idea. ;) I’m all about the chocolate.

  287. Maria B
    Reply

    My favorite combo is strawberry and cheesecake. I might try making this ice cream using the cheesecake instant pudding and some yummy fresh strawberries!

    Thank you!

  288. Shari
    Reply

    I think I’m in love! All of my favorite flavors together in ice cream form? I don’t think I will be able to share once I get it made!

  290. Robin
    Reply

    I am a huge peanut butter fan and my husband is a banana pudding lover…his mom always makes it for him the from scratch custard kind…can’t wait to try this ice cream!

  291. Emily
    Reply

    I love peanut butter and chocolate, but my husband and I discovered the combo of marshmallow and caramel in a concrete from Culvers!

  298. Ellen
    Reply

    This recipe is my perfect ice cream combo! I adore banana pudding, love anything with peanut butter, and of course adore chocolate so this sounds like heaven. Can’t wait to try it out (too bad I didn’t see this before I made my shopping trip for the week…next time!)

  300. Kristin Pickett
    Reply

    This looks delicious!! My favorite combo is Oreo cookies, peanut butter in coffee flavored ice cream. Mouth watering!!

  304. Emilie
    Reply

    OOOH I love all sweets so this is hard. But I do adore the banana split flavor! Fresh banana and strawberries + vanilla bean + hot fudge, mmmm

  310. Kimberly
    Reply

    I’d have to say anything with heath bar & coffee. My favorite combo EVER! Or strawberry cheesecake ice cream with graham cracker chunks… Mmm.

  314. Kate W.
    Reply

    I’m actually pretty enamored of the pb/banana/chocolate combo, but because I just can’t quit I also add marshmallows to the mix :)

  322. Heather
    Reply

    Um, YUM! I am making this to go with my homeade waffle cones! I was going to say peanut butter and chocolate are my favorite combinations, but now I have to add bananas to the mix. Thanks for sharing.

  325. JAmie S
    Reply

    This looks super yummy!!! I love Chocolate ice cream with anything chocolate in it. However this looks really yummy! I think will be making this for our camping trip in a few weeks!!1

  331. Jesseca
    Reply

    Key lime pie. I put about 1/4 c. lime juice, and one cup of crushed graham crackers! We’ve been living off of this stuff all summer!

  334. Evil Pixie
    Reply

    For me, it is a toss-up between two combinations: Chocolate, peanut butter, and banana OR chocolate, caramel, and pecans. My mouth is watering just thinking about it.

  335. Tabitha Lambert
    Reply

    My husband LOVES ice cream!!! This is such an awesome giveaway!!! I am new to your website and I just can’t get enough of it!!! :)

  346. Kimberli
    Reply

    What a fun giveaway!! I’m all for a classic combo, peanut butter and chocolate!! Thanks for the chance to win and your ice cream recipe, I’ve been meaning to make it since you posted it the first time!!

  349. Jan N
    Reply

    Oh. My. Goodness. I will be trying this recipe and soon! I LOVE anything with caramel. Or chocolate. Or peanut butter. Or mint. Did you just want one answer? Sorry.

  353. Rebecca
    Reply

    This sounds amazing! I cannot wait to try it!! My favorite ice cream combo is vanilla ice cream, oreo, chocolate fudge, and graham cracker crust. YUM!

  359. Mrs.K Rasmussen
    Reply

    This is the PERFECT recipe!!Banana’s, Chocolate, and Peanut Butter… There is nothing better for me that this very combo! I can’t wait to try it!!

  374. Sheila B
    Reply

    Mmmmmmmmm! It’s all about peanut butter and chocolate for me! Mint chocolate chip and peanut butter is a close second! Thanks , you guy’s!!!

  376. Sara
    Reply

    I love vanilla ice cream with mocha powder sprinkled on top with whipped cream and a cherry (…or two). It’s super yummy! :)

  383. Kimbrell
    Reply

    Can’t wait to try this recipe. Have made many recipes from your blog & love them all. Plus anything with Eagle Brand condensed milk has got to be good.

  395. Brenda McCracken
    Reply

    My favorite combo. would be cinnamon and pumpkin. With fall arriving in a few month,I would love to make a fall pudding using these ingredients.

  400. JaanL
    Reply

    I am an ice cream crazy, got it from my Dad. My fav is dark chocolate and peppermint ice cream, in a cup or cone….oh, so yummy.

  401. Lauren Conner
    Reply

    Peanut butter and banana is one of my favorite combinations!! Adding chocolate or honey to that would would be yummy!!! :)

  402. Melissa judd
    Reply

    I’m obsessed With any chocolate ice cream But nothing beats m&ms and chocolate chip cookie dough thrown in!!!!! Yummy!!! Thanks for the awesome chance to win such a fun and exciting prize :-)

  412. CARISSA
    Reply

    I think your recipe here is my new favorite combo! Going to try this ASAP! My usual favorite is hot fudge and peanut butter!!!

  415. Alyssa Smith
    Reply

    Yum! This looks so delish! I can’t wait to make it. Ice cream is definately my weekness!! My best combo is cake batter w/ sprinkles… nom nom nom :o)

  417. Sally
    Reply

    I have to admit, I’m a “hot-fudge” girl all the way, BUT… a little caramel never hurt anyone! LOL Thanks for the chance to win! ~Sally

  419. Jenn T.
    Reply

    When I was breastfeeding my 3rd child, I had huge PB cravings. I’d just scoop it out on top of chocolate ice cream! My favorite combination is a dark, dutch chocolate ice cream with PB swirls (thick swirls!) and maybe, if I’m in the mood, some marshmallows, too. (But no nuts – don’t like nuts in my ice cream!)

  436. Miranda
    Reply

    I’m a Cookies and Cream lover – so I always go for Oreos in my homemade K&A ice cream. If I’m feeling ambitious, I also add brownies and caramel. So sinful. So good.

  444. Katie P
    Reply

    While the banana ice cream you made looks absolutely amazing, I’m deathly allergic to bananas, so that one is unfortunately out of the question. I’d have to say that blueberries with crumbled bits of homemade graham-cracker crust mixed into vanilla ice cream would be my choice. While I haven’t tried this yet as the inspiration was reading about Smuckers’ new blueberry topping, I’ll be trying this out soon. Like, today. :)

  453. Tammy
    Reply

    There is no doubt this recipe rocks. It is hard to go wrong with peanut butter ;). My favorite toppings for ice cream include some crushed Butter Fingers, chocolate syrup, nuts, and whipped cream. All of them at once. Every time. Makes a girl happy. Especially a pregnant girl :)

  454. Athena R
    Reply

    OMG! I have got to make this ice cream. My fav ice cream combo is peanut butter and chocolate, but this might be my second fav!

  455. Ali
    Reply

    I love anything with caramel and nuts. Yum! I’ve also made this type of ice cream with mint extract and mini choclate chips. My niece was helping me and instead of the usual green coloring we added purple. It looked great! :)

  462. Tasha Phillips
    Reply

    I love a good vanilla ice cream with a hot or warm topping…and oreos…chocolate…caramel…well, you get my drift!

  466. Kiersten
    Reply

    Sweet and salty! Hmmmm.. maybe a new flavor combo could be caramel with crushed pretzel pieces? I’m already craving it!!!

  467. Esther T.
    Reply

    I think my favorite combo has to be either red wine/chocolate or raspberries/chocolate. Adore both!
    I, like you, am not a big fan of banana pudding, but my son-in-law is. He also loves chocolate and peanut butter, so I’m gonna give the ice cream a try and surprise him!

  469. Sonia Marie
    Reply

    Usually anything with banana, peanut butter & yellow cake is my favorite, but now I can see this becoming my new favorite!! I don’t know why i never thought about vanilla wafers!

  471. Ellie A.
    Reply

    Oh I am SUPER DUPER Squealing! My kids are so gonna give me that crown of Rockin mom when I make this (I’ll give you credit too ha) As for best combo I’d have to say Vanilla w/Carmel & bits of Chocolate oh pure happiness indeed! Thanks for the chance.

  479. Meghan
    Reply

    Loveee this recipe and the simplicity of not needing an ice cream machine! My perfect flavor combo is definitely anything chocolate and peanut butter as well!

  488. Tonia Ruck
    Reply

    I love caramel and peanuts and chocolate swirls and thick vanilla ice cream. Tin Roof is as close as I get to what I love. :) This giveaway is making me hungry! lol

  492. TobyD
    Reply

    Chocolate and coffee!!! What a neat idea for ice cream!!!! I will have to make some with my ice cream loving daughter, thank you!!

  496. Ruth
    Reply

    peanut butter and chocolate is my favorite mix!! My friend made for my birthday the recipe you have on here for the peanut butter and chocolate cake… mmmmm! It was delicious!

  501. Sarah
    Reply

    I love caramel and chocolate! YUM. Chocolate and banana is also delicious! Chocolate and peanut butter too! Oh goodness, I have too many favorites, I just can’t choose!

  517. Rachael Strickland
    Reply

    Thanks for sharing this! My uncle is one of the top executives of Smuckers! I love their company :) What a great recipe. I just love PB and chocolate combinations :) Mmmm!

  522. Hip Foodie Mom
    Reply

    Fave flavor combo? your recipe here captures it! :) Chocolate and peanut butter- definitely! :) Thank you for the chance at a giveaway and a GREAT recipe! I am def going to try this one!

  523. Jen A.
    Reply

    My favorite combo would have to be chocolate, marshmallows and almonds (Rocky Road, anyone?)! Banana pudding comes in a close second, though!

  524. CATHY SIZEMORE
    Reply

    I CAN NOT WAIT TO MAKE THIS. SOUNDS DELICIOUS. ALWAYS LOVE YOUR BLOGS SO MUCH AND TRY AS MANY OF THE IDEAS AS I CAN.

    YOU NEED TO GO ON ANOTHER TRIP SO WE CAN ENJOY THE PICTURES!!

    HOPE I WIN!

  536. KellyRae
    Reply

    Yum! Sorry Amanda, I am totally with Kevin on this flavor combo. My DH is the one that turns up his nose at my flavor choices (lol). I make peanut butter, chocolate, and banana milk shakes all the time. This fabulous ice cream recipe is one I will be trying very soon. Thank you and thank Smuckers for a chance at this wonderful prize.

  538. Southern Gal
    Reply

    I just wanna lick the monitor right now. Oh.my.goodness.

    My perfect combination has little bit of caramel, some cookie crumbles and strawberries. Strawberry Blondie.

  539. Tracey
    Reply

    Peanut butter and chocolate is my favorite combo!

    I don’t mind some banana thrown into the mix, though, so will definitely be trying this recipe! Thanks!

  541. Christine
    Reply

    Pouts…I didn’t get the update email until MONDAY Aug. 6th (looks like I’m not the only one since all the comments posted today too, none before). Did the contest really end yesterday?

    I’m thinking I’m going to try this with a chocolate pudding, mix in some maraschino cherries and then some chocolate chips. Can’t wait to try this out.

  546. Gina M.
    Reply

    I enjoy banana and salted caramel with nuts! I usually will top vanilla bean ice cream with bananas and Trader Joe’s Fleur de Sel caramel sauce, and then whatever nut I have on hand…cashews are delicious. In fact, I could probably put all of those ingredients in your 2 ingredient ice cream!! yum. :)

  548. Jacqui
    Reply

    I am exactly like Kevin! My favorite flavor combination ever is chocolate, peanut butter and banana! It cannot be beat :-)

  553. Susan LP
    Reply

    While I will have to make the banana pudding /peanut butter for my husband, Iwould do chocolate, strawberry and toasted pecan for me.

  555. Betsy B.
    Reply

    Mmmmmmm … Yummy!!! I’d put peanut butter, chocolate chunks, and pretzels in mine! I love that sweet/salty combo!!!
    Thanks for the chance to win!!!

  566. Jennifer
    Reply

    This looks like such an easy, delicious recipe! I love the idea of banana pudding ice cream. My favorite ice cream combination is cake batter ice cream with Oreos.

  569. Julia
    Reply

    My favorite ice cream flavor is strawberry, with nothing else on it. But, I also love chocolate and PB – so this recipe is looking pretty amazing!

  573. Susan K.
    Reply

    My favorite ice cream has to have some kind of nut in it. Any kind – but there has to be something with some bite, and big enough hunks to be noticeable! Whole pecans come to mind! YUM!

    Thanks for the chance to win. I will definitely try your recipe, but with added roasted peanuts! DIVINE!

  575. Corisa
    Reply

    My favorite flavor combo no matter the meal has to be sweet and salty ! I love chocolate peanut butter pretzels! Especially in ice cream too!

  582. Candice S. in Colorado
    Reply

    Oh wow, this looks so incredibly awesome! And….since I have had tons of my daughter’s friends over all summer, this would just make my year!!!!

    My favorite combo would be chocolate and caramel. Or chocolate and peanut butter! I am not picky! LOL!!!!
    Thanks for this fun chance to win!!!

    xo,
    Candice in Colorado
    candice1973(at)comcast(dot)net

  584. Christina
    Reply

    This ice cream sounds amazing! I love all things with sweetened condensed milk. I have a can of it in my fridge for making the most delicious ice coffee ever!

  585. Melinda
    Reply

    I love salty-sweet and crunchy-creamy combos. It’s difficult to choose just one flavor, but since that’s what you asked…today, I’d have to say my favortie combo is salty caramel with pieces of Twix or Biscoff cookies :)

  590. Cathy
    Reply

    My grandson would absolutely love the banana and peanut butter one, but me just give me a jar of caramel and the jar of walnuts in sauce….mmmmmmm.

  591. Dawn
    Reply

    I love this easy ice cream recipe. My favorite combo would be oreos and peanut butter. This does remind me of the chic fil a banana pudding milk shake which I love!

  594. Lisa
    Reply

    I love Coffee Ice Cream with Roasted Almonds, Heath Toffee Bar and Caramel…it’s called Coffee Lovers at Coldstone Creamery! SOOO good!!

  600. Kayla Clark
    Reply

    My perfect flavor would be hot fudge, and chopped nuts (without peanuts!!) Can’t wait to try this!!! It will be the perfect “treat before Mom goes back to school” seeing how I start school a week before my own kids go to their school. The joys of being a teacher:)

  606. Connie R.
    Reply

    My birthday is Aug.16 I would so love to win this so I could make me some homemade ice Yumm. Thanks so much for the chance to win.

  611. Grisel Blanco
    Reply

    Pistachio Ice-cream (minus the nuts), pound cake and just a little hint of caramel, not to take away from the exquisite pistachio exotic taste! Mmmm, mmm, GOOD!!! *drooling*

  615. Sara
    Reply

    I like my ie cream with peanut butter chunks or swirls….but I would like to try this with some “cookies and cream” too! Ya can’t go wrong with cookies and peanut butter! I wonder if almond butter would be tasty too?!

  616. Janie Hammes
    Reply

    my favorite ice cream combination is pistachio almond but, I am sure going to have to give this one a try it sounds so yummy!

  618. David Miles (@IlloDave)
    Reply

    A little late to enter? Maybe… but I love a good Chocolate Banana Malt. Yum! Although it is hard to choose a favorite combo when you are talking about sweets ;).

  621. Averie @ Averie Cooks
    Reply

    Amanda this looks amazing and so clever! Fave combo would be vanilla with chocolate and caramel swirls and chunks of toffee. Today. Could change tomorrow.

  627. Wendy W.
    Reply

    Oh. My. WORD. I am seriously considering taking the rest of the day off so I can make this ice cream … and I just GOT here. Peanut butter ice cream is my favorite … although plain old vanilla with peanut butter sauce is pretty darn awesome, too :)

  637. Sandy_in_MD
    Reply

    I like the banana and peanut butter combo, but I think I would also throw in a handful of mini choclate chips – yum! Thanks for the chance to win.

  643. KellyM
    Reply

    My favorite combo would be chocolate syrup with chocolate chips. I’ve been wanting to try to make my own icecream but thought it would be too hard – you made it look INCREDIBLY easy!!! Thanks Amanda!

  647. DebbieB
    Reply

    This looks delicious! I tried your ice cream recipe with Nutella which turned out great. I’m definitely going to try this one. I like banana, chocolate and walnuts combination!

  648. Candy
    Reply

    My husband LOVES ice cream! Going to try making him some homemade.

    Our fav is chocolate with pecans or almonds. Thanks for the chance to win this awesome give-away!

  649. NANCY GRIFFIN
    Reply

    I WOULD LOVE TO WIN THIS GIFT THE GRANDKIDS AND I WOULD HAVE A BALL. MY FAVORITE WOULD BE STRAWBERRY AND HOT FUDGE.
    THANKS FOR A CHANCE,
    NANCY
    P.S. I ENJOY ALL YOUR PHOTOS

  654. Gretta List
    Reply

    Your ice cream looks delish! I’ll definatelly have to try that one. My favorite is chocolate with caramel and pecans. Turtle ice cream! Love it!

  658. Katrina @ Warm Vanilla Sugar
    Reply

    This is such a great ice cream and I love this giveaway! My favorite flavour combo is peanut butter and chocolate…such a classic!

  659. Natalie
    Reply

    Who knew ice cream was this easy to make? I have to try this! My favorite ice cream combo is vanilla ice cream with chocolate and peanut butter. Ribbons of peanut butter. =)

  663. Jennifer Fredericks
    Reply

    My favorite flavor combo is chocolate….and everything else! :) This recipe looks AMAZING though! I absolutely have to try it!

  666. Erin
    Reply

    My favorite combination is vanilla ice cream with mini rolo’s and caramel folded in topped with hot caramel, hot fudge, and fresh whipped cream with a few chocolate sprinkles – I discovered this not too long ago and now I’m addicted.

  670. Vera Zecevic - Cupcakes Garden
    Reply

    Wowww! It looks so delicious! I must try this recipe! Creamy staff have always been my favorite! Regards

  672. Mandee J
    Reply

    I love chocolate & coffee. The two together is super yummy!
    My husband would love this flavor! He loves peanut butter & banana, too!

  678. Elizabeth Rhyneer
    Reply

    Ingredients are already on my grocery list and it will be as you made it, sounds great.

    Not sure about your date to enter the contest, Sunday, August 5th was yesterday. Maybe my email notification is behind. Thanks

  686. Erin @ Texanerin Baking
    Reply

    Can’t enter the contest but I love that Kevin specified that he only wanted swirls (me too!) :) All I get from my husband when asked what he’d like is, “Eh, I don’t care. Whatever.”

    I love that this comes out of the freezer creamy! I’ve been making a lot of frozen yogurt and it’s always hard as a rock after it’s been in the freezer overnight. And this sounds like an amazing flavor combination. Wow.

  687. Betty Spitzberg
    Reply

    Oh wow, your creation sounds heavenly. I love peanut butter & chocolate together so my ice cream would made with that & maybe some sort of coffee flavoring. Yum

  690. tracy
    Reply

    How fun is this recipe. And no ice cream maker required! If I had motivation to make my own ice cream flavor it would definitely include chocolate, waffle cone, nuts, and maybe some caramel. Mmmm… making me want some now!

  692. Amy Tong
    Reply

    My perfect flavor combo would be chocolate, raspberries and hazelnut. hm…I’m craving for some right now.

    amy [at] utry [dot] it

  693. Christy
    Reply

    Seriously, THIS combo sounds like my dream. I, too, LOVE banana pudding and anything with peanut butter! My hubby has been wanting to try his hand at making ice cream and we will definitely be doing this recipe! :-)

Do you have a question or comment?

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

Meet Kevin & Amanda

Kevin and Amanda

We love to travel and to eat! Here we share our favorite quick and easy recipes, plus travel tips and guides for our favorite places around the world. If you have any questions about what camera I use or how I edit my photos, check out my photography tutorials.

READ MORE

Subscribe via Email: